Dividend investing is often about balancing yield with sustainability. The strategy behind the "Best Dividend Stocks" screen is to avoid chasing the highest yield blindly, which can sometimes be a trap. Instead, the screen first filters for solid financial health and profitability using ChartMill’s proprietary ratings. Only then does it apply a strict minimum for the dividend rating, ensuring that the companies selected not only pay a decent dividend but are financially stable enough to maintain or grow it over time. This approach aims to find stocks that offer a reliable income stream without taking on excessive risk.
One stock that emerges from this screen is PT Telkom Indonesia (Persero) Tbk, listed as Telkom Indonesia (ADR) (NYSE:TLK). With a ChartMill Dividend Rating of 7 out of 10 and a Profitability Rating of 7 out of 10, it meets the core criteria of the strategy. However, a deeper look at the fundamental report reveals both the appeal and the cautions that dividend-focused investors need to consider.
Dividend Yield and Growth
The most eye-catching figure for any income investor is the dividend yield. Telkom Indonesia currently offers a very high yearly dividend yield of 9.00%. This is significantly higher than the industry average of 2.33% and far above the S&P 500’s average yield of 1.78%. The company also has a solid track record, having paid a dividend for at least 10 years and growing its payout at an average annual rate of 6.64%. This combination of a high yield and a history of growth is rare and strong.
However, the screen’s requirement for profitability and health is crucial here. A high yield can sometimes be a red flag if the share price has fallen sharply, which is the case here—the stock price dropped -22.34% in the last three months. This price decline is a warning sign that the market is worried about something, which is why the screen's additional criteria are so important: we need to verify the company’s ability to maintain that dividend.
Sustainability and Valuation
The most critical metric for dividend sustainability is the payout ratio. Unfortunately, Telkom Indonesia’s payout ratio stands at 128.74%. This means the company is paying out more in dividends than it earns in net income, which is not sustainable over the long term. This is a significant point of caution and highlights why the screen does not rely on yield alone.
That said, the company’s underlying cash flow and earnings growth projections offer some balance. The debt is well-managed (Debt to FCF ratio of 1.74, meaning it could pay off all debt in under two years with free cash flow), and the earnings per share (EPS) are expected to grow by 19.48% annually in the coming years. This strong forecasted growth could eventually bring the payout ratio back to a more comfortable level.
On the valuation front, the stock appears cheap. With a Price/Earnings (P/E) ratio of 15.14 and a Price/Forward Earnings ratio of 9.77, it is trading at a significant discount to both its industry peers and the broader S&P 500. This valuation, combined with the high yield, makes it a classic value and income play.
Profitability and Health
The screen’s filters ensure that the high yield isn’t coming from a company in financial distress. Telkom Indonesia scores well here, with a Profitability Rating of 7. The company has had positive earnings and operating cash flow for each of the last five years. Its Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) of 11.80% is excellent, outperforming nearly 95% of its industry peers. This suggests the company is efficiently turning its capital into profits.
The Health Rating of 6 is decent but not without flaws. The company is solidly solvent, with a manageable Debt/Equity ratio of 0.36, but its Current Ratio of 0.92 and Quick Ratio of 0.91 are below 1.0, which is a sign of potential short-term liquidity pressure. This is the weaker link in the health assessment but is partially offset by the strong solvency metrics.
Analyst Views
Looking at the broader fundamental data, the stock’s PEG Ratio based on expected growth suggests it is undervalued when considering future earnings acceleration. The combination of a low P/E with an expected EPS growth rate of 19.48% provides a strong case for capital appreciation on top of the dividend income.
Conclusion
Telkom Indonesia presents a classic high-yield dilemma. The 9.00% dividend yield is extraordinarily attractive, and the company has the profitability and decent long-term health to support it. The primary risk lies in the unsustainable payout ratio and the recent sharp price decline, which may signal deeper issues. For a dividend investor following the screen’s methodology, this stock is a strong candidate for further research, not an automatic buy. It perfectly illustrates why a high yield must be evaluated in the context of payout ratios and earnings growth.
If you want to explore more stocks that pass the same rigorous filters, including minimums for health, profitability, and dividend ratings, you can run the full Best Dividend Stocks screen yourself via this link to find more dividend opportunities.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always conduct your own research before making any investment decisions.
Read full article here »
View the Zacks #1 Rank List
Telkom Indonesia (NYSE:TLK): A High-Yield Dividend Play with Cautionary Signals
Dividend investing is often about balancing yield with sustainability. The strategy behind the "Best Dividend Stocks" screen is to avoid chasing the highest yield blindly, which can sometimes be a trap. Instead, the screen first filters for solid financial health and profitability using ChartMill’s proprietary ratings. Only then does it apply a strict minimum for the dividend rating, ensuring that the companies selected not only pay a decent dividend but are financially stable enough to maintain or grow it over time. This approach aims to find stocks that offer a reliable income stream without taking on excessive risk.
One stock that emerges from this screen is PT Telkom Indonesia (Persero) Tbk, listed as Telkom Indonesia (ADR) (NYSE:TLK). With a ChartMill Dividend Rating of 7 out of 10 and a Profitability Rating of 7 out of 10, it meets the core criteria of the strategy. However, a deeper look at the fundamental report reveals both the appeal and the cautions that dividend-focused investors need to consider.
Dividend Yield and Growth
The most eye-catching figure for any income investor is the dividend yield. Telkom Indonesia currently offers a very high yearly dividend yield of 9.00%. This is significantly higher than the industry average of 2.33% and far above the S&P 500’s average yield of 1.78%. The company also has a solid track record, having paid a dividend for at least 10 years and growing its payout at an average annual rate of 6.64%. This combination of a high yield and a history of growth is rare and strong.
However, the screen’s requirement for profitability and health is crucial here. A high yield can sometimes be a red flag if the share price has fallen sharply, which is the case here—the stock price dropped -22.34% in the last three months. This price decline is a warning sign that the market is worried about something, which is why the screen's additional criteria are so important: we need to verify the company’s ability to maintain that dividend.
Sustainability and Valuation
The most critical metric for dividend sustainability is the payout ratio. Unfortunately, Telkom Indonesia’s payout ratio stands at 128.74%. This means the company is paying out more in dividends than it earns in net income, which is not sustainable over the long term. This is a significant point of caution and highlights why the screen does not rely on yield alone.
That said, the company’s underlying cash flow and earnings growth projections offer some balance. The debt is well-managed (Debt to FCF ratio of 1.74, meaning it could pay off all debt in under two years with free cash flow), and the earnings per share (EPS) are expected to grow by 19.48% annually in the coming years. This strong forecasted growth could eventually bring the payout ratio back to a more comfortable level.
On the valuation front, the stock appears cheap. With a Price/Earnings (P/E) ratio of 15.14 and a Price/Forward Earnings ratio of 9.77, it is trading at a significant discount to both its industry peers and the broader S&P 500. This valuation, combined with the high yield, makes it a classic value and income play.
Profitability and Health
The screen’s filters ensure that the high yield isn’t coming from a company in financial distress. Telkom Indonesia scores well here, with a Profitability Rating of 7. The company has had positive earnings and operating cash flow for each of the last five years. Its Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) of 11.80% is excellent, outperforming nearly 95% of its industry peers. This suggests the company is efficiently turning its capital into profits.
The Health Rating of 6 is decent but not without flaws. The company is solidly solvent, with a manageable Debt/Equity ratio of 0.36, but its Current Ratio of 0.92 and Quick Ratio of 0.91 are below 1.0, which is a sign of potential short-term liquidity pressure. This is the weaker link in the health assessment but is partially offset by the strong solvency metrics.
Analyst Views
Looking at the broader fundamental data, the stock’s PEG Ratio based on expected growth suggests it is undervalued when considering future earnings acceleration. The combination of a low P/E with an expected EPS growth rate of 19.48% provides a strong case for capital appreciation on top of the dividend income.
Conclusion
Telkom Indonesia presents a classic high-yield dilemma. The 9.00% dividend yield is extraordinarily attractive, and the company has the profitability and decent long-term health to support it. The primary risk lies in the unsustainable payout ratio and the recent sharp price decline, which may signal deeper issues. For a dividend investor following the screen’s methodology, this stock is a strong candidate for further research, not an automatic buy. It perfectly illustrates why a high yield must be evaluated in the context of payout ratios and earnings growth.
If you want to explore more stocks that pass the same rigorous filters, including minimums for health, profitability, and dividend ratings, you can run the full Best Dividend Stocks screen yourself via this link to find more dividend opportunities.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always conduct your own research before making any investment decisions.
Read full article here »