The energy sector has been a tale of two industries in recent weeks. While crude oil prices have come under pressure, dragging down the performance of upstream producers, the downstream refining segment is seeing a strong divergence. The market is rewarding companies that capture widening crack spreads and convert crude into finished products, with refiners posting explosive earnings growth and solid technical momentum, even as the broader sector corrects.
Valero Energy Corp (NYSE:VLO) is a textbook example of this refiner leadership. The company has been a standout, with technical strength ranking in the 92nd percentile of all stocks. This momentum is built on an extraordinary improvement in operating margins and a massive earnings inflection.
- ChartMill Relative Strength: 92.15 (Top 8% of all stocks)
- EPS Growth (Q/Q): +374.2%
- Operating Margin Growth (1Y): +159.1%
- Performance (1 Month): +8.8%
The driving force behind VLO's rally is a surge in profitability. The 374% jump in quarterly earnings is directly linked to a more than doubling of operating margins over the past year. This shows that the company is fully capturing the benefits of a favorable refining environment. While the trailing P/E of 20 is not cheap on an absolute basis, the forward P/E of 13.2 suggests earnings are expected to remain elevated, justifying the current valuation tier.
Marathon Petroleum Corp (NYSE:MPC) has followed a similar pattern, with technical strength at the 90th percentile. The company has delivered an even more dramatic earnings explosion, signaling a highly favorable margin environment for independent refiners.
- ChartMill Relative Strength: 90.35 (Top 10% of all stocks)
- EPS Growth (Q/Q): +787.5%
- Operating Margin Growth (1Y): +56.7%
- Return on Equity: 27.6%
The 787% EPS growth is the clearest signal that MPC is operating in a period of exceptional profitability. This has pushed the trailing P/E to the high 20s, but the forward P/E of just 11.9 implies the market is pricing in a normalization of earnings. With an ROE of 27.6%, MPC is generating strong returns on its capital, and the dividend payout ratio of only 25% leaves ample room for shareholder returns via buybacks or future dividend increases.
Phillips 66 (NYSE:PSX) rounds out the refiner trio with a technical rank of 86. While its quarterly earnings growth of 154% is less extreme than its peers, the improvement in operating margins is noteworthy, suggesting a similar tailwind from crack spreads.
- ChartMill Relative Strength: 85.95 (Top 14% of all stocks)
- EPS Growth (Q/Q): +154.4%
- Operating Margin Growth (1Y): +326.5%
- Forward P/E: 10.8
The 326% operating margin growth is the most striking figure here, indicating that PSX is also benefiting from wide margins. The stock has modestly lagged VLO and MPC over the past month, but its forward P/E of 10.8 is the lowest among the three refiners, suggesting the market may be underestimating its earnings potential for the coming year.
The picture is starkly different for the upstream producers. EOG Resources Inc (NYSE:EOG) offers a contrasting story. While the company is a high-quality operator with a strong balance sheet, it lacks the momentum of the refiners, highlighting the current divergence.
- P/E: 12.5
- Forward P/E: 8.9
- EPS Growth (Q/Q): +18.8%
- ChartMill Relative Strength: 46.9
EOG is demonstrably cheap, trading at a P/E of 12.5 and a forward P/E of under 9. Its balance sheet is rock-solid, with a debt-to-equity ratio of just 0.26. However, its relative strength of 46.9 shows it is a laggard, and the 4.4% decline over the past month reflects the market's concern over lower realized commodity prices. This represents a clear quality-versus-momentum trade-off.
Suncor Energy Inc (NYSE:SU), an integrated operator with both upstream and downstream exposure, sits somewhere in the middle. It has posted decent recent performance but also lacks the explosive momentum of the pure-play refiners.
- P/E: 16.1
- Forward P/E: 10.6
- EPS Growth (Q/Q): +47.3%
- ChartMill Relative Strength: 78.4
SU’s relative strength of 78.4 is respectable, and its forward P/E of 10.6 suggests value. The 47% EPS growth is solid but does not compare to the triple-digit figures from the refiners. SU appears to be trading at a reasonable valuation and is likely being supported by its downstream operations, but it has not generated the same level of excitement as VLO or MPC.
You can view the complete list of companies in this theme at the Oil and Gas Stocks page.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.
Read full article here »
View the Zacks #1 Rank List
Refiners Outshine Producers as Widening Crack Spreads Fuel Massive Earnings Growth
The energy sector has been a tale of two industries in recent weeks. While crude oil prices have come under pressure, dragging down the performance of upstream producers, the downstream refining segment is seeing a strong divergence. The market is rewarding companies that capture widening crack spreads and convert crude into finished products, with refiners posting explosive earnings growth and solid technical momentum, even as the broader sector corrects.
Valero Energy Corp (NYSE:VLO) is a textbook example of this refiner leadership. The company has been a standout, with technical strength ranking in the 92nd percentile of all stocks. This momentum is built on an extraordinary improvement in operating margins and a massive earnings inflection.
The driving force behind VLO's rally is a surge in profitability. The 374% jump in quarterly earnings is directly linked to a more than doubling of operating margins over the past year. This shows that the company is fully capturing the benefits of a favorable refining environment. While the trailing P/E of 20 is not cheap on an absolute basis, the forward P/E of 13.2 suggests earnings are expected to remain elevated, justifying the current valuation tier.
Marathon Petroleum Corp (NYSE:MPC) has followed a similar pattern, with technical strength at the 90th percentile. The company has delivered an even more dramatic earnings explosion, signaling a highly favorable margin environment for independent refiners.
The 787% EPS growth is the clearest signal that MPC is operating in a period of exceptional profitability. This has pushed the trailing P/E to the high 20s, but the forward P/E of just 11.9 implies the market is pricing in a normalization of earnings. With an ROE of 27.6%, MPC is generating strong returns on its capital, and the dividend payout ratio of only 25% leaves ample room for shareholder returns via buybacks or future dividend increases.
Phillips 66 (NYSE:PSX) rounds out the refiner trio with a technical rank of 86. While its quarterly earnings growth of 154% is less extreme than its peers, the improvement in operating margins is noteworthy, suggesting a similar tailwind from crack spreads.
The 326% operating margin growth is the most striking figure here, indicating that PSX is also benefiting from wide margins. The stock has modestly lagged VLO and MPC over the past month, but its forward P/E of 10.8 is the lowest among the three refiners, suggesting the market may be underestimating its earnings potential for the coming year.
The picture is starkly different for the upstream producers. EOG Resources Inc (NYSE:EOG) offers a contrasting story. While the company is a high-quality operator with a strong balance sheet, it lacks the momentum of the refiners, highlighting the current divergence.
EOG is demonstrably cheap, trading at a P/E of 12.5 and a forward P/E of under 9. Its balance sheet is rock-solid, with a debt-to-equity ratio of just 0.26. However, its relative strength of 46.9 shows it is a laggard, and the 4.4% decline over the past month reflects the market's concern over lower realized commodity prices. This represents a clear quality-versus-momentum trade-off.
Suncor Energy Inc (NYSE:SU), an integrated operator with both upstream and downstream exposure, sits somewhere in the middle. It has posted decent recent performance but also lacks the explosive momentum of the pure-play refiners.
SU’s relative strength of 78.4 is respectable, and its forward P/E of 10.6 suggests value. The 47% EPS growth is solid but does not compare to the triple-digit figures from the refiners. SU appears to be trading at a reasonable valuation and is likely being supported by its downstream operations, but it has not generated the same level of excitement as VLO or MPC.
You can view the complete list of companies in this theme at the Oil and Gas Stocks page.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.
Read full article here »