Peter Lynch’s philosophy of “growth at a reasonable price” remains one of the most durable frameworks for long-term stock picking. By focusing on companies that combine steady earnings growth, strong financial health, and a valuation that doesn’t demand perfection, the strategy aims to avoid both the hype of overpriced growth stocks and the traps of declining value plays. A recent screen based on Lynch’s core criteria has identified Copart, Inc. (NASDAQ:CPRT) as a candidate worth examining.
Business Profile
Copart operates a global online vehicle auction and remarketing platform. Its primary customers are insurance companies that need to sell vehicles declared a total loss, but the company also serves rental agencies, banks, charities, and fleet operators. With over 200 locations across 11 countries and more than 175,000 vehicles available for auction daily, Copart has built a logistics-heavy network that competitors would find difficult to replicate. This kind of “dull but essential” business model is exactly the type Lynch favored — a straightforward operation that dominates a niche market without needing to chase the latest trend.
Meeting the Peter Lynch Criteria
The screening process applies Lynch’s well-known filters, and Copart clears each of them by a comfortable margin.
- EPS Growth (5-year average): 20.02% – Lynch looked for growth above 15% but below 30%, believing that excessively high expansion rates are rarely sustainable. Copart’s 20% compound annual growth sits right in the sweet spot.
- PEG Ratio (based on 5-year growth): 0.85 – A PEG below 1.0 is Lynch’s threshold for reasonable valuation. Copart’s PEG of 0.85 suggests that investors are paying less for each unit of earnings growth than the growth rate itself would justify.
- Debt/Equity Ratio: 0.0 – Lynch preferred companies that avoid heavy debt burdens. Copart carries no outstanding debt, which not only eliminates interest expense but also provides financial flexibility during downturns.
- Current Ratio: 7.61 – A current ratio above 1.0 ensures that short-term assets cover short-term liabilities. A figure above 7.0 signals exceptionally strong liquidity, meaning the company has no trouble meeting its obligations.
- Return on Equity (ROE): 17.70% – Lynch required ROE above 15% as evidence of effective capital deployment. Copart’s ROE is comfortably above that hurdle and ranks well within the top quartile of its industry.
These criteria work together to filter out companies that are either too risky, too expensive, or too unprofitable for a long-term hold. Copart’s numbers suggest it fits the profile of a business that can compound steadily without the drag of excessive debt or the risk of a valuation correction.
Fundamental Report Summary
A deeper look into the fundamental analysis report paints a picture of a company with strong profitability and excellent financial health, offset somewhat by a maturing growth trajectory.
Profitability is a standout. Copart’s profit margin of 33.48% leads its industry, and its operating margin of 36.57% is equally dominant. Return on assets, return on equity, and return on invested capital all rank among the best in the sector. These metrics confirm that Copart is not just growing — it is doing so with high and stable margins.
Financial health is equally impressive. The company has zero debt and an Altman-Z score of 20.19, which is far above the traditional “safe” threshold of 3.0. The current and quick ratios both exceed 7.5, meaning there is no liquidity stress whatsoever. On the negative side, the company has been increasing its share count slightly over the past year and five years, which is a point Lynch would have disliked.
Growth is where the picture becomes more nuanced. While the 5-year average EPS growth of 20% is strong, the most recent year showed only 5.92% growth, and revenue growth slowed to 1.05%. Future expectations are moderate, with analysts forecasting average EPS growth of around 6% per year. The deceleration in growth rates is the main reason the overall fundamental score settles at a 6 out of 10 rather than higher.
Valuation is reasonable but not dirt-cheap. The trailing P/E of 17.07 is well below the S&P 500 average of 26.42 and also cheaper than nearly 80% of industry peers. The forward P/E of 15.97 offers a similar picture. Given the strong profitability and solid balance sheet, the current valuation does not appear stretched, although it offers less margin of safety than a true deep-value play.
Why This Matters for Long-Term Investors
The Peter Lynch approach is not about finding the fastest-growing company or the cheapest stock. It is about identifying businesses that can grow earnings at a sustainable pace, trade at a reasonable multiple, and maintain a fortress-like balance sheet through economic cycles. Copart checks most of those boxes. Its dominant position in vehicle remarketing gives it pricing power and recurring revenue, while its debt-free structure means earnings are not at the mercy of interest rates.
The moderation in recent growth is worth watching, but it does not necessarily break the thesis. Lynch himself warned against companies growing too fast, and a shift from 20% to a more sustainable mid-single-digit growth rate could still produce solid total returns if the valuation holds or expands modestly.
For investors who want to screen for similar candidates, the Peter Lynch strategy screen is available to run with the same filters used here. You can find more companies that meet these criteria and perform your own research before making any decisions.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always conduct your own due diligence before buying or selling any security.
Read full article here »
View the Zacks #1 Rank List
Copart (NASDAQ:CPRT): A Growth at a Reasonable Price Stock Meeting Peter Lynch Criteria
Peter Lynch’s philosophy of “growth at a reasonable price” remains one of the most durable frameworks for long-term stock picking. By focusing on companies that combine steady earnings growth, strong financial health, and a valuation that doesn’t demand perfection, the strategy aims to avoid both the hype of overpriced growth stocks and the traps of declining value plays. A recent screen based on Lynch’s core criteria has identified Copart, Inc. (NASDAQ:CPRT) as a candidate worth examining.
Business Profile
Copart operates a global online vehicle auction and remarketing platform. Its primary customers are insurance companies that need to sell vehicles declared a total loss, but the company also serves rental agencies, banks, charities, and fleet operators. With over 200 locations across 11 countries and more than 175,000 vehicles available for auction daily, Copart has built a logistics-heavy network that competitors would find difficult to replicate. This kind of “dull but essential” business model is exactly the type Lynch favored — a straightforward operation that dominates a niche market without needing to chase the latest trend.
Meeting the Peter Lynch Criteria
The screening process applies Lynch’s well-known filters, and Copart clears each of them by a comfortable margin.
These criteria work together to filter out companies that are either too risky, too expensive, or too unprofitable for a long-term hold. Copart’s numbers suggest it fits the profile of a business that can compound steadily without the drag of excessive debt or the risk of a valuation correction.
Fundamental Report Summary
A deeper look into the fundamental analysis report paints a picture of a company with strong profitability and excellent financial health, offset somewhat by a maturing growth trajectory.
Profitability is a standout. Copart’s profit margin of 33.48% leads its industry, and its operating margin of 36.57% is equally dominant. Return on assets, return on equity, and return on invested capital all rank among the best in the sector. These metrics confirm that Copart is not just growing — it is doing so with high and stable margins.
Financial health is equally impressive. The company has zero debt and an Altman-Z score of 20.19, which is far above the traditional “safe” threshold of 3.0. The current and quick ratios both exceed 7.5, meaning there is no liquidity stress whatsoever. On the negative side, the company has been increasing its share count slightly over the past year and five years, which is a point Lynch would have disliked.
Growth is where the picture becomes more nuanced. While the 5-year average EPS growth of 20% is strong, the most recent year showed only 5.92% growth, and revenue growth slowed to 1.05%. Future expectations are moderate, with analysts forecasting average EPS growth of around 6% per year. The deceleration in growth rates is the main reason the overall fundamental score settles at a 6 out of 10 rather than higher.
Valuation is reasonable but not dirt-cheap. The trailing P/E of 17.07 is well below the S&P 500 average of 26.42 and also cheaper than nearly 80% of industry peers. The forward P/E of 15.97 offers a similar picture. Given the strong profitability and solid balance sheet, the current valuation does not appear stretched, although it offers less margin of safety than a true deep-value play.
Why This Matters for Long-Term Investors
The Peter Lynch approach is not about finding the fastest-growing company or the cheapest stock. It is about identifying businesses that can grow earnings at a sustainable pace, trade at a reasonable multiple, and maintain a fortress-like balance sheet through economic cycles. Copart checks most of those boxes. Its dominant position in vehicle remarketing gives it pricing power and recurring revenue, while its debt-free structure means earnings are not at the mercy of interest rates.
The moderation in recent growth is worth watching, but it does not necessarily break the thesis. Lynch himself warned against companies growing too fast, and a shift from 20% to a more sustainable mid-single-digit growth rate could still produce solid total returns if the valuation holds or expands modestly.
For investors who want to screen for similar candidates, the Peter Lynch strategy screen is available to run with the same filters used here. You can find more companies that meet these criteria and perform your own research before making any decisions.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always conduct your own due diligence before buying or selling any security.
Read full article here »